A costed alternative to closureA realistic budget and a willing delivery partner give the council an alternative it can assess.
The plan may change how the school is run. Agreed partners and recurring funding still need demonstrating here.
Full explanation and sources
A credible alternative gives decision-makers a choice they could put into practice. Model a smaller intake, shared leadership, a federation or suitable use of spare space, with a realistic plan for staff and funding.
Rules in force from 1 September 2026 replace the leaflet’s claim that amalgamation requires a new free school. Current guidance describes altering a surviving maintained school or, subject to conditions, creating a replacement maintained school. A legal route does not supply a willing partner, funding or suitable premises. Council leaflet · Prescribed alterations guidance · Opening new schools guidance.
What a full assessment needs
Compare three-year budgets with low, central and high pupil numbers and actual class and staffing costs. Allow for any delay before pupil changes affect income. School, governor and council agreement would be needed; none is approved here.
Test the alternatives on the same terms
- Shared leadership or federation: the FAQ’s £50,000–£80,000 savings range alone leaves £132,417–£162,417 against the first-year gap. This is subtraction, not a committed saving; check whether savings are already assumed.
- A smaller intake or different site use: cost actual cohorts, classes, curriculum and support. Lettings need permissions and net income after extra costs; spare space alone does not balance the budget.
- Amalgamation or a different organisation running the school: name the willing partners and legal route; cost staffing and set-up, and check which teaching and site would remain.
- A limited recovery period: agree funding, a spending limit, review dates and what happens if pupil numbers or savings fall short. Waiting until a PFI end date is not a free or agreed solution.
One-off fundraising does not meet recurring costs. Recruitment remains school-owned and completely separate from this closure campaign.
Sources: Kew FAQ Q5 and shared-leadership range, Q11. Current legal guidance and remaining evidence.
Limits and unanswered questions
Keeping teaching on site may change the school’s identity or how it is run. The existing-school and replacement-school routes have different procedures; September 2026 guidance also has transitional rules for earlier proposals. Agree which outcome matters and check premises/PFI permissions, timing and costs.
Closing maintained schools: statutory guidance · School financial information · The school's private finance initiative arrangement